
Various Artists
I'm Not There [Music From The Motion Picture]
Columbia
As a soundtrack for his forthcoming Bob Dylan movie I'm Not There, director Todd Haynes has assembled an impressive array of musicians young and old to provide cover versions and re-workings of their favourite Dylan tracks.
Much like the Wylde Rattz project for Hayne's previous rock biopic Velvet Goldmine, supergroup "The Million Dollar Bashers" (featuring Lee Ranaldo, Steve Shelley, Nels Cline and Tom Verlaine among others) back many of the singers, and were put together to bring some cohesiveness to the album. As a cohesive album however, I'm Not There fails conclusively. Clocking in at a whopping 160 minutes, the jam-packed double CD is simply far too long - eclipsing the sprawling White Album and making Red Hot Chili Pepper's 2006 opus Stadium Arcadium seem like a couple of bonus tracks.
Taken as a collection of individual tracks however, the album provides a wealth of ammo for the mixtape masses with more than a few silver bullets in the arsenal. With such great material in the hands of these artists it would have been a tragedy for this album to be a faliure, but cover songs have always been a hit or miss affair - with the artists often taking one of two methods of attack when approaching the material. The most effective method here seems to be the straightforward approach, letting the bands own sound soak through the material. Sonic Youth's understated cover of I'm Not there is a highlight, as are Steven Malkmus' multiple contributions adding only a few restrained theatrics to produce some of his best work.
Black Keys provide one successful modernisation with their fuzz metal version of The Wicked Messenger, but The Hold Steady's version of Can You Please Crawl Out Your Window tries too hard to fit Dylan's square song into the band's story-telling style of a round hole. Not to mention Sufjan Steven's overblown theatrics, which make Ring Them Bells (what else?) smugly saccharine. Eddie Vedder's All Along The Watchtower would make for a live concert highlight, but it sounds pretty straightforward here - as does Cat Power's solid, but karaoke-like cover of Stuck Inside of Mobile - following Dylan's version down to the tiniest vocal shift, in a way that even he refuses to do in his live show.
Some minor disappointments come from artists who have covered Dylan's work so well previously - such as Pearl Jam's version of Masters Of War or Jim James' superb Billy 4. Jim James covers Goin' To Acapulco on this album, which is a mild let-down when My Morning Jacket could have done a blistering version of something like Hurricane - particularly after they so perfectly blended their own heavy rocking style into Freebird in the woeful Elizabethtown movie.
For all of this, it's the breadth of Dylan's songwriting that is the star of the show - with 70's cowboy-era Dylan coming out particularly well. Calexico's multiple contribution's provide much of that, as do Los Lobos' spirited break for the border with Billy 1. It's when the musicians' really grasp the spirit of the songs that things really work - and while Cat Power's uninspired rendering illustrates Dylan's occasionally drawn out verses, John Doe's version of Pressing On and Ramblin' Jack Elliot's guitar picking on Tom Thumb's Blues provide a celebration of the music itself, rather than just the lyrics.
34 tracks picked from Dylan's catalogue of literally hundreds is in itself quite an achievement, resulting in an album so dense that it's taken me an extra week just to get to grips with it all. If it was actual Dylan versions it might be up their with Mothership in this year's best of (disqualified on a best-of technicality). And in fact, since hearing this album I have drawn up such a playlist, which is working out nicely.
Links
Tags
20th Nov 2007 - Tumblr
3News
Reviews
Articles
Surveillance
Related
Soul
Another touching Pixar tale from Pete Docter. Stylish and inspiring.
29th Dec 2020
Read more 4 star reviewsSearch
The Christmas Chronicles
Perfect Christmas movie that sails close to the wind of parody without getting swept away.
26th Dec 2020
Read more 4 star reviewsBack to the Future III
Stirring, straight shooting, well rounded finale to a classic trilogy.
13th Dec 2020
Read more 4.5 star reviewsBack to the Future II
Note perfect, brisk, entertainingly convoluted classic.
13th Dec 2020
Read more 5 star reviewsBack to the Future
Genre defining 80s classic that still hits all the right notes.
13th Dec 2020
Read more 5 star reviewsOn the Rocks
Unsurprisingly slight, but the one thread of plot is held together by an enjoyable Bill Murray.
21st Nov 2020
Read more 3.5 star reviewsRichard Jewell
Incredibly straightforward Clint drama, anchored by some great central performances.
10th Nov 2020
Read more 3.5 star reviewsThe Witches
Not exactly imaginative re-imagining, but it gets the job done in the right spirit.
1st Nov 2020
Read more 3 star reviews1917
Ambitious, stagey epic. Plenty of tropes and it falls in all the usual 1-take potholes.
27th Oct 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsA Beautiful Day in the Neighbourhood
Thoughtful, stylish drama with a zen central performance.
17th Oct 2020
Read more 4 star reviewsWho Framed Roger Rabbit
Stiff, poorly paced innovative film that hasn’t aged well.
11th Oct 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsOnward
Inspiring, tightly scripted gem - overlooked by lockdown.
4th Oct 2020
Read more 4 star reviewsThe Informer
Standard-issue airplane movie, with Joel Kinnaman standing in for Vin Diesel.
3rd Oct 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsMotherless Brooklyn
Sub LA Confidential gumshoe thriller - with an underplayed USP. Ed Norton misses again.
27th Sep 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsGlass
Over explained threequel, that undermines a low key original.
18th Sep 2020
Read more 2.5 star reviewsSnowpiercer
Intriguing, but generally incomprehensible sci-fi gobbledegook.
31st Aug 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsJumani
The Next Level
Marginally less fun sequel, but still plenty of laughs.
16th Aug 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsThe Deer Hunter
Beautifully imagined and lovingly restored, but it still alternates between a snail's pace and feeling like a trailer edit.
12th Aug 2020
Read more 4 star reviews21 Bridges
Surprisingly enjoyable plane movie, though it owes a lot to the magnificent Copland.
8th Aug 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsAd Astra
Incredibly stylish and wannabe cerebral sci-fi, that’s ultimately a little thin.
19th Jul 2020
Read more 3.5 star reviewsFirst Man
Underwhelming space drama that’s a bit too intimate and not very epic.
5th Jul 2020
Read more 3.5 star reviewsBlue Story
Dire, tension-free postcode gang drama. Just add drama.
21st Jun 2020
Read more 1 star reviewsApollo 11
Magnificent documentary, re-assembling the moon landing from beautifully remastered footage.
14th Jun 2020
Read more 4 star reviewsOnce Upon A Time In Hollywood
The 8th slow-paced Tarantino pic. Literally half entertaining / boring.
24th May 2020
Read more 2.5 star reviewsYesterday
Entertaining Brit-com, though it’s a bit on-the-beaten-path for Danny Boyle.
13th Apr 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsJuliet, Naked
Mildly enjoyable, thoroughly forgettable Nick Hornby pic ...once you get past the contrived set up.
4th Apr 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsThe Lion King
Impeccably realised remake, but it’s emotionally flat.
15th Mar 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsGalveston
Standard festival thriller, with some style and decent moments - but it’s all a bit thin.
10th Mar 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsAlladin
Surprisingly enjoyable, Guy Ritchie-fied Disney remake.
10th Mar 2020
Read more 3.5 star reviewsMapplethorpe
Cookie cutter biography that could literally have been written from his Wikipedia page.
7th Mar 2020
Read more 1.5 star reviewsHorse Girl
Text book indie, literally days out of Sundance. Interesting until it gets a bit too wacky.
9th Feb 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsPhantom Thread
Considered character study that strays into pretentiousness here and there.
25th Jan 2020
Read more 3 star reviewsRocketman
Enthusiasticly directed sequence of unrelated musical set pieces.
31st Dec 2019
Read more 3 star reviewsAvengers
Endgame
Yet another biggest-battle-yet, with more than a passing nod to BTTF2.
30th Dec 2019
Read more 3 star reviewsMystify
Michael Hutchence
Thoughtfully assembled montage doc.
30th Dec 2019
Read more 3.5 star reviewsCaptain Marvel
Decent origin story, with charm and some 90s nostalgia.
27th Dec 2019
Read more 3 star reviewsStar Wars
The Rise of Skywalker
Freestyle bouillabaisse with all the ingredients, but no chef.
27th Dec 2019
Read more 3 star reviewsMarriage Story
Quintessential indie movie ...funded by Netflix. Great perfs, lovely camera work and solid direction.
22nd Dec 2019
Read more 4 star reviewsWidows
Superior modern thriller. Smart script and accomplished direction.
15th Dec 2019
Read more 4 star reviewsThe Irishman
Long, slow, thoroughly enjoyable loose jam through Scorsese/DeNiro/Pacino/Pesci/Keitel’s greatest hits.
2nd Dec 2019
Read more 4 star reviewsJoker
Batman via Scorsese, in impeccably art directed, neatly packaged origin story.
28th Nov 2019
Read more 4 star reviewsFrozen 2
Surprisingly strong sequel that gets going after a convoluted start.
24th Nov 2019
Read more 3 star reviewsThe Mule
Casual drama from Clint Eastwood, with the man himself anchoring things through a charming turn.
16th Nov 2019
Read more 3 star reviewsThe King
Luscious period drama. Beautifully put together - like Wolf Hall+.
3rd Nov 2019
Read more 3.5 star reviewsEl Camino
Throw away Breaking Bad expansion piece with little tension or jeopardy.
13th Oct 2019
Read more 2.5 star reviewsVice
Stylish but incoherent Cheney biopic, hampered by another one-note turn from Bale.
5th Oct 2019
Read more 3 star reviews